GET /api/v0.1/hansard/entries/?format=api&page=136605
HTTP 200 OK
Allow: GET, POST, HEAD, OPTIONS
Content-Type: application/json
Vary: Accept

{
    "count": 1608389,
    "next": "http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/?format=api&page=136606",
    "previous": "http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/?format=api&page=136604",
    "results": [
        {
            "id": 1382461,
            "url": "http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1382461/?format=api",
            "text_counter": 347,
            "type": "speech",
            "speaker_name": "Nakuru Town East, UDA",
            "speaker_title": "Hon. David Gikaria",
            "speaker": null,
            "content": "in my constituency were given some work without gumboots and gloves. They were earning Ksh1500 per week, but they could end up spending Ksh10,000 because of injuries from"
        },
        {
            "id": 1382462,
            "url": "http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1382462/?format=api",
            "text_counter": 348,
            "type": "scene",
            "speaker_name": "",
            "speaker_title": "",
            "speaker": null,
            "content": "msumari"
        },
        {
            "id": 1382463,
            "url": "http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1382463/?format=api",
            "text_counter": 349,
            "type": "speech",
            "speaker_name": "Nakuru Town East, UDA",
            "speaker_title": "Hon. David Gikaria",
            "speaker": null,
            "content": ", for example. They could end up treating themselves using Ksh20,000 to Ksh30,000. So, it depends. Yes, you have received something, but at what cost? What are you leaving us with after you have taken all that is underneath the ground? So, there is need for enforcement of a system of benefit sharing in natural resource exploitation amongst the natural resource exploiters, the national Government, the county governments and the local community. Hon. Temporary Speaker, most of the people who come to mine are from outside the country. So, what do they do? They mine as much as they can. Then what happens? All the profits generated are taken back to their countries. If it is China, it is taken back to China. For example, Tullow Oil in Turkana, which is a British company, would have made some profits but of what benefit would it be? Would they just be taking all the profit back to their motherland? Some natural resources are finite, which means if we use them continuously, we will eventually exhaust them. It is true that every resource is in quantities. After years of exploitation, it will be depleted. It is for this reason that the Constitution of Kenya mandates Parliament to enact legislation on the exploitation of natural resources. Just like the other Motion that we have just passed, Parliament has been given a big role. It is important for us to look at legislation, and whatever comes to this House, beyond our political boundaries and parties and talk about Kenya. It is for that purpose that we look at some of the pieces of legislation that we come up with, not because it is going to assist a certain area for a period of time. We need to be nationalists when it comes to law-making. I remember sometime back we travelled to Israel when I was a member of the Committee on Administration and Internal Security. There are different political parties in Israel but they told us that when it comes to the security of Israel, everybody becomes an Israeli and they forget about their parties. This is because they have to protect their country and her people. It is that common interest that we all need to look at. When I was the Chairperson of the Committee on Energy, I remember the time we were legislating on the petroleum revenue sharing mechanism. There are many differences between Turkana County and West Pokot County. The oil is in Turkana County. It is true that it is there, and it is in plenty. For you to extract oil in Turkana, you must get water from West Pokot County. Water is used to push out oil. These are some of the things they say might even bring conflict. West Pokot said it could not give out water to enrich Turkana, and if it had to, they had to split the resource down the middle. Those are conflicts between counties. It is unfortunate that grazing might bring an issue. A simple thing like grazing brings many problems between communities. The electronic version of the Official Hansard Report is for information purposesonly. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Hansard Editor"
        },
        {
            "id": 1382464,
            "url": "http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1382464/?format=api",
            "text_counter": 350,
            "type": "speech",
            "speaker_name": "Nakuru Town East, UDA",
            "speaker_title": "Hon. David Gikaria",
            "speaker": null,
            "content": "Permit me to highlight the important provisions in the Bill. First, the Bill is applicable to a number of natural resources. The first one is the sunlight. What resource? Of course, solar. If you are to undertake a solar project in Garissa, that is a resource you need. Second is underground water. Again, this comes between counties. Where is this bed of water underneath here? Maybe, it is a boundary between three or four counties. It talks about forests, biodiversity and genetic resources. Baobab trees from Kilifi have been an issue in our Committee. People are actually taking away the heritage of this country. They are going to plant those Baobab trees in their country. Imagine a farmer being paid only Ksh100,000 and yet, the cost of transportation of the same baobab tree from Kilifi to the Netherlands is almost Ksh10 million. What profit or benefit will a farmer who is paid only Ksh100,000 get? Yet, he spent so much money on transport. Some of the issues we are talking about include biodiversity, genetic resources, wildlife resources, industrial fishing in the lake region and Mombasa, wind power, thermal resources, minerals and petroleum. The Bill has introduced a benefit sharing provision. In as far as natural resources are concerned, it has proposed the establishment of a benefit sharing authority. This is, therefore, a money Bill because it is creating an authority which will draw money from the exchequer. Article 114 of the Constitution says that all money Bills must originate from the National Assembly. We need advice because it is pointless to debate a matter that is unconstitutional. This is because it will find its way to court and we will blame the judges for doing the right thing. If the Constitution says all money Bills must originate from the National Assembly, any money Bill originating from elsewhere is unconstitutional. Hon. Temporary Speaker, as a senior legal counsel, you know that there is nothing much we can do about an unconstitutional matter. So, the proposed benefit sharing authority will facilitate benefit sharing agreements among the affected counties, entities and local communities. It will determine the royalties and fees payable to certain sectors, where a written law does not prescribe. As I said, this is an unconstitutional legislation and it will remain so. The Bill provides for revenue collected to be shared in the ratio of 60 per cent to the national Government and 40 per cent to the respective county governments. Additionally, at least 60 per cent of the revenue assigned to the county governments shall be used for local community projects and 40 per cent for the benefit of the entire county. This Bill provides that county assemblies will sit to determine how the money will be spent. For example, Nakuru Town East Constituency, where I come from, has urban wards and rural wards. What happens? The urban wards collect a lot of revenue unlike the rural wards but, when sharing revenue in our respective wards, the urban wards are disadvantaged. Members of County Assembly (MCAs) from the rural wards gang up against the urban wards MCAs despite the fact that between 60 per cent and 70 per cent of the total county revenue comes from. This creates inequity. If we are giving so much, why should we get so little? Also, you find that one ward is very tiny while another ward is geographically big. This Bill proposes that the county assemblies decide on how to share resources. Whatever is discussed in the county assembly does not benefit the county because they disagree a lot since everybody sticks to their side. Where the natural resources are shared by two or more counties, the authority shall, in consultation with the affected counties, determine the benefit sharing ratio among themselves. This will create war between counties. For example, Turkana will never agree with West Pokot on resource sharing matters. This was an observation made by the Committee through public participation. The Bill proposes that each county with a natural resource shall establish a county benefit sharing committee. This creates other problems because it does indicate when they will sit or where they will draw their allowances from. Is it from the share going to the county, community or national Government? The proposed benefit sharing ratio is very confusing. For example, if three counties claim to share geothermal resources, which are underground, will The electronic version of the Official Hansard Report is for information purposesonly. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Hansard Editor"
        },
        {
            "id": 1382465,
            "url": "http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1382465/?format=api",
            "text_counter": 351,
            "type": "speech",
            "speaker_name": "Nakuru Town East, UDA",
            "speaker_title": "Hon. David Gikaria",
            "speaker": null,
            "content": "every county constitute its own committee to make decisions? So, the Committee looked into the sharing formula proposed in the Bill. Mining and minerals are a reserve of the national Government. This is well established in the Constitution and detailed in the Mining Act, 2016. The role of county governments is limited to implementation of specific national Government policies. Our Constitution classifies land as private, public or community. Who is vested with powers of owning that land? Mostly, it is county governments. Our Constitution says that, where minerals are underneath the land, they become the property of the national Government. So, it is giving county governments overlapping functions and this will not work. This Bill presents constitutional and administrative implementation challenges by assigning national functions to county governments. This is the overlap we saw. As I said, it originated from the Senate because they were looking for some work to do. Even though I am not a lawyer, I know that Article 61 of the Constitution stipulates that land belongs to the county governments but minerals underneath belong to the national Government. Benefit sharing is specific to a sector and several Acts of Parliament governing natural resources have already set out benefit sharing frameworks. For instance, last year, we passed the Climate Change (Amendment) Bill, 2023 on carbon projects. That Bill provides clauses on how the national Government, the county governments and the respective communities will benefit from selling carbon credits. I think the percentages are 15 per cent to national Government, 10 per cent to county governments and 5 per cent to the community. The common benefit sharing ratio for renewable and non-renewable extractive resource is, therefore, inequitable by failing to consider the unique nature of each resource. So, we cannot compare sand with gold or important minerals that are used to make phones and laptops. We need to separate resources. This Bill is not doing so. The Mining Act, 2016 provides for determination of royalties payable. I want to speak on the thinking of the current administration about mining. The Kwale community collected royalties worth Kshs4 billion. Royalties payable were almost Ksh1 billion to the county. Once the county gets the money, the community is put at the back seat. The community is asking about the Ksh1 billion they were given as royalties for titanium. They are the people who are feeling the brunt of environmental degradation and yet, the county government has put that money on something else. This is where the county marginalises or refuses to release the money to the respective communities that are affected. That is something we were looking into. There are major overlaps of the Bill with existing legislation."
        },
        {
            "id": 1382466,
            "url": "http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1382466/?format=api",
            "text_counter": 352,
            "type": "speech",
            "speaker_name": "Nakuru Town East, UDA",
            "speaker_title": "Hon. David Gikaria",
            "speaker": null,
            "content": "The Bill proposes creation of a benefit sharing authority, which presents additional costs of governance of natural resources and a potential overlap with other Government agencies that are mandated to manage and license the use of natural resource in various sectors. This will present management and administrative challenges. What we are trying to say is that the Bill proposes to create those bodies without telling us where the money to run them will come from. The money is expected to come from the Exchequer and yet, we are already talking about a very heavy wage bill. The Bill proposes that we create that body and have the revenue sharing committees at the county level. All these are wage bill issues we need to consider. When you introduce an authority, a board and an office of director-general or whoever as it is indicated in this bill, it raises a lot of other issues."
        },
        {
            "id": 1382467,
            "url": "http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1382467/?format=api",
            "text_counter": 353,
            "type": "speech",
            "speaker_name": "Nakuru Town East, UDA",
            "speaker_title": "Hon. David Gikaria",
            "speaker": null,
            "content": "The Bill is not also clear on how funds for implementing local community projects will be budgeted, accounted for and such matters reported separately from the revenue assigned to the county governments to be utilised for the benefit of the entire county. Let us assume that we will give that money, as the Bill proposes, and we leave it in the wilderness for the county governments to decide on how to use it. Even if a county government decides to fund a community project, the Bill does not tell us how such project will be identified and The electronic version of the Official Hansard Report is for information purposesonly. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Hansard Editor"
        },
        {
            "id": 1382468,
            "url": "http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1382468/?format=api",
            "text_counter": 354,
            "type": "speech",
            "speaker_name": "Nakuru Town East, UDA",
            "speaker_title": "Hon. David Gikaria",
            "speaker": null,
            "content": "implemented. We will be creating funds for people without accountability on their usage even though those funds are meant to benefit the local communities."
        },
        {
            "id": 1382469,
            "url": "http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1382469/?format=api",
            "text_counter": 355,
            "type": "speech",
            "speaker_name": "Nakuru Town East, UDA",
            "speaker_title": "Hon. David Gikaria",
            "speaker": null,
            "content": "Hon. Temporary Speaker, the Committee noted that this is a money Bill, pursuant to Article 114 of the Constitution. As such, it can only be introduced in the National Assembly pursuant to Article 109 (5) of the Constitution. In accordance with the Constitution, the National Treasury has to give its input where a money Bill is concerned. On many amendments with financial implications that have been brought to House, the Hon. Speaker has always told us that the Constitution does not allow us to proceed with such amendments. Having considered the Bill, for the foregoing reasons, the Committee recommends that the House rejects the Bill in its entirety."
        },
        {
            "id": 1382470,
            "url": "http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1382470/?format=api",
            "text_counter": 356,
            "type": "speech",
            "speaker_name": "Nakuru Town East, UDA",
            "speaker_title": "Hon. David Gikaria",
            "speaker": null,
            "content": "In conclusion, I implore upon Members consider the comprehensive Report by the Departmental Committee on Environment, Forestry and Mining as they debate this Bill so that they may make informed decisions. Members should also appreciate the concerns that came out of the public participation. Out of the 19 stakeholders and Government agencies that appeared before the Committee, only four supported the Bill. The others rejected it."
        }
    ]
}