{"count":1608389,"next":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/?format=json&page=136536","previous":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/?format=json&page=136534","results":[{"id":1381761,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381761/?format=json","text_counter":263,"type":"scene","speaker_name":"","speaker_title":"","speaker":null,"content":"(Putting of the Question on the Bill deferred)"},{"id":1381762,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381762/?format=json","text_counter":264,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"The Deputy Speaker","speaker_title":"","speaker":null,"content":"Let us go to the next Order."},{"id":1381763,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381763/?format=json","text_counter":265,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"The Deputy Speaker","speaker_title":"","speaker":null,"content":"The electronic version of the Senate Hansard Report is for information purposes only. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Director, Hansard Services, Senate."},{"id":1381764,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381764/?format=json","text_counter":266,"type":"heading","speaker_name":"","speaker_title":"","speaker":null,"content":"BILL"},{"id":1381765,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381765/?format=json","text_counter":267,"type":"scene","speaker_name":"","speaker_title":"","speaker":null,"content":"Second Reading"},{"id":1381766,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381766/?format=json","text_counter":268,"type":"heading","speaker_name":"","speaker_title":"","speaker":null,"content":"THE COUNTY BOUNDARIES BILL (SENATE BILLS NO.6 OF 2023)"},{"id":1381767,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381767/?format=json","text_counter":269,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"Sen. M. Kajwang’","speaker_title":"","speaker":{"id":13162,"legal_name":"Moses Otieno Kajwang'","slug":"moses-otieno-kajwang"},"content":"Mr. Deputy Speaker, Sir, I beg to move that the County Boundaries Bill (Senate Bills No.6 of 2023) be read a Second Time. This Bill is not foreign to the Senate and Senators. This is the fourth attempt by Parliament to have a legislative framework that gives effect to Article 188 of the Constitution which talks about alteration of county boundaries. This Bill had previously been brought to this House under the sponsorship of Sen. Mutula Kilonzo Jnr. There were about three attempts. There have been all sorts of arguments against the approach that we had taken in the past. At some point, the National Assembly vetoed it saying that it was a Money Bill; that it was proposing a charge on the consolidated fund. This Bill died due to lack of concurrence between the Speakers of both Houses. However, this is an important legislation. The team that was in Bomas of Kenya, the National Dialogue Committee (NADCO) flagged the issue of county boundaries as one of the key issues around cohesion that needed to be dealt with. I took note that whereas the NADCO made certain legislative proposals for the other pieces that they felt should be enacted, when it came to the County Boundaries Bill, the NADCO proposed that the Bill that is currently before Parliament should be fast tracked. I do hope that this time, this Bill will get bi-partisan and bi-cameral support. The objective of this Bill is to give effect to Article 188 of the Constitution. The territory of Kenya is defined in Article 6 as comprising of the 47 counties that have been listed in the First Schedule of the Constitution. The question has been, why do we have 47 counties and not 13 or fewer like Sen. (Dr.) Khalwale has been reported saying that we need fewer counties? Mr. Deputy Speaker, Sir, the team that was drafting the new Constitution retreated in Naivasha. There was a rush to have a Constitution that will be acceptable to all Kenyans. Initially, there was a formation that was in favour of counties along the lines of the existing provinces. There was a middle ground that was considering 13 counties. However, the team that carried the day is the one that convinced the committee meeting in Naivasha that we adopt the 46 districts plus Nairobi City as captured in the Districts and Provinces Act of 1992. If you ask me what the logic was, I believe some of the people who were in Naivasha are here. Sen. Mungatana was in the House around that time. I hope we will benefit from their wisdom so that they can tell us what science there was. Sen. (Dr.) Khalwale was also around and was very much involved in that process. There was no magic. We just said let us take the District and Provinces Act of 1992. The electronic version of the Senate Hansard Report is for information purposes only. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Director, Hansard Services, Senate."},{"id":1381768,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381768/?format=json","text_counter":270,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"Sen. M. Kajwang’","speaker_title":"","speaker":{"id":13162,"legal_name":"Moses Otieno Kajwang'","slug":"moses-otieno-kajwang"},"content":"In 1992, Kitui County had just been split. It had gotten a new district. However, that new district had not been gazetted as at the time people were in Naivasha. That is why the Senator for Kitui County still feels that we should have a 48th county along the lines of the districts that were there then. That is the reason why we have 47 counties. Whether they are economically viable or not is a completely different question. Are the boundaries natural, man-made or have been gerrymandered to take into account certain clan or tribal issues? I guess that is still up for discussion. Another vexing question is where do counties begin and end? Last week, in Nyamira and Kisii counties, otherwise, very good neighbours; they speak the same language and have the same history, people are fighting over a market in Keroka. You ask yourself what this market has to do to challenge age old cultural ties, people who speak the same language from the same clans. If you are not careful, you will lose lives. Between Vihiga and Kisumu counties, there is a big fight about Maseno. There is no Session that we have held and we have not had a petitioner from Vihiga County. In fact, it keeps the committees on Devolution and Intergovernmental Relations and that of Lands, Environment and Natural Resources very busy on issues to do with Vihiga County. Makueni and Taita Taveta counties are fighting over a centre called Mtito Andei. It is driven by concerns around revenue. The governor of Makueni County wants to collect revenue in Mtito Andei and the people of Taita Taveta are saying that is historically their town. Sometimes I fail to understand why we neighbours have to fight over issues of boundary, yet these are communities that have known each other even before they knew the white man. The people who live in Kisumu County and those in Kericho County are mostly Luos and members of the Kalenjin community. We knew each other before we knew the colonialists. However, issues of boundaries separate us. There have been issues in Isiolo and Meru counties. It is on record that there are about 40 Petitions with regard to county boundaries. Some of those Petitions have come before the Senate others have gone to the National Lands Commission (NLC) and others have found their way in court. Where counties end and begin is not captured in the Constitution. The Constitution only lists the 47 counties. However, that description of where counties start and end is captured in the District and Provinces Act of 1992. Sen. Mungatana will tell you that the language used in the District and Provinces Act leaves a lot to be desired. This is because some language is not very accurate. Some of it is descriptive, some of it refers to natural features which because of climate change might not be there anymore and some of it refers to rivers and streams. It is important we ensure that we concretise these issues to avoid the conflicts that we have seen around the counties. It might also be useful for Senators to note that whereas in 1992 we had 46 plus one district, plus one, meaning Nairobi. Between 1992 and 2002, President Moi had created 30 additional districts. By the time people were going to Naivasha to consider the new Constitution, there were close to 77 districts. So, people had to go back to 1992 as a better benchmark. The electronic version of the Senate Hansard Report is for information purposes only. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Director, Hansard Services, Senate."},{"id":1381769,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381769/?format=json","text_counter":271,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"Sen. M. Kajwang’","speaker_title":"","speaker":{"id":13162,"legal_name":"Moses Otieno Kajwang'","slug":"moses-otieno-kajwang"},"content":"How do you resolve these disputes across boundaries? We have tried. When I chaired the Committee on Devolution and Intergovernmental Relations, the matter of Vihiga and Kisumu counties came before us. Unfortunately, we responded to the petitioners that the Senate shall enact legislation to give effect to Article 188. Senate sounded fairly helpless because we were not giving the petitioners a solution. We were giving them a promise. The only other alternative would have been for them to go to court. The courts would still bring them back to the Senate because they cannot enact laws. This Bill, in attempting to provide a framework for dealing with boundary disputes, establishes the County Boundaries Mediation Committee as the first instance for dealing with boundary disputes. The County Boundaries Mediation Committee is an adhoc Committee. It is not going to be a permanent thing. It acts upon resolutions of the Senate. So, it has to be moved by the Senate. It is appointed by the President and it comprises of officers of the national Government and those from county governments. During public participation, I saw there was need to include the National Cohesion and Integration Commission (NCIC) as part of the County Boundaries Mediation Committee. That is an amendment I find reasonable. We probably need to have the NCIC being part of this. Other members are from the NLC, a representative from surveyors, one from the Council of Governors (CoG) and I believe we can include the NCIC. Clause 5 of this Bill is clear on how our request to Senate should be shaped and submitted for the establishment of a County Boundaries Mediation Committee. That Committee can have various proposals. It can propose that the boundaries be altered. If the County Boundaries Mediation Committee proposes that the boundaries be altered, then we go to Article 188 of the Constitution. It talks of reasons that could lead to alteration of county boundaries. An interesting reading of Article 188 is that it sounds like once those conditions have been fulfilled, a commission has been established by the President and it reports that a boundary should be altered, then that alteration takes effect. I have been looking at Article 188 and comparing with Article 255 that says that anything that affects the structure of devolved Governments is subject to a referendum. Article 188 sounds very final. Mr. Deputy Speaker, Sir, these are some of the areas that we need to look into. This is because Article 188 of the Constitution, from a plain reading, means that you can alter county boundaries without necessarily going into a referendum, and yet, it alters the structure of devolved governments. This Bill has proposed a very high threshold. For you to propose the alteration of the boundary of a county, you must be supported by at least 50 percent of registered voters in that county. Once you have satisfied that threshold, there will be a commission established by the President that will still have to be subjected to the Senate. Once you get 15 per cent of registered voters, you submit it to the Senate. The Senate will establish a special committee. The electronic version of the Senate Hansard Report is for information purposes only. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Director, Hansard Services, Senate."},{"id":1381770,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381770/?format=json","text_counter":272,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"Sen. M. Kajwang’","speaker_title":"","speaker":{"id":13162,"legal_name":"Moses Otieno Kajwang'","slug":"moses-otieno-kajwang"},"content":"If the Senate agrees with you, it forwards the request to the National Assembly. If the National Assembly agrees with the Senate, then the President establishes a commission within 90 days. If there was to be a decision on alteration, it must be supported by two-thirds of Members of both Houses. Two-thirds of Members of both Houses is a threshold in the Constitution. However, the question would remain, even with two-thirds of Members proposing the alteration of county boundaries, should it go to a referendum. We will be relying on bright lights like Sen. Cherarkey to put together Article 188 and Article 255 of the Constitution and advise whether we should amend this legislation further to make it mandatory for a referendum. Otherwise, Article 188 ends with approval by two-thirds and then the boundaries are altered. There is the other question of creating new counties. How do you create new counties? This Bill does not address that subject because, for you to create new counties, you must go into a referendum to alter Article 16 which defines Kenya as comprising the 47 counties in the First Schedule. For you to amend the First Schedule, you must go into a referendum. So, this Bill only deals with boundary disputes and cases where there is a need to alter the boundaries of existing counties. The challenge with the Districts and Provinces Act, which this Bill seeks to repeal, is that the boundaries are described in a very narrative form in many cases. There are very few counties where the boundaries are expressed in forms of Global Positioning System (GPS) coordinates. This Bill makes it mandatory for the Cabinet Secretary to maintain an electronic register using the latest advanced technologies to ensure that county boundaries are mapped and captured using Geographic Information System (GIS) or GPS; the relevant technology. It makes it an offense for anyone to alter those records. That is captured in Clause 3 of the Bill. The Schedule that we have attached to this Bill has been captured as is from the Districts and Provinces Act. Many colleagues here have expressed their concern that, that Schedule, sometimes the way it has described those boundaries, is a bit tricky. Unfortunately, we do not have any other point of preference because when people went to Naivasha, they referred to the Districts and Provinces Act, and that then became part of the Supreme Law. Therefore, if you go back and try to rewrite the Districts and Provinces Act, you will end up in a lot of problems because no Kenyan will accept that you move the existing boundaries, even by a single inch. The alteration of boundaries and even issues of mediation must be subjected to serious public engagement. Mr. Deputy Speaker, Sir, even as I move, I am still asking myself, that if you have got a petition from county X, for example, Vihiga County, has moved Parliament to alter the boundary. How do you capture the voice of the people of Kisumu; assuming the boundary would be moving and carving Maseno to be part of the Vihiga County? Just as an example. I know Sen. Osotsi is firmly convinced that Maseno is part of Vihiga County, and we are entitled to our own opinions, but not to our facts. The facts might look a bit different. However, if the people of Vihiga County initiate that Motion and they can convince Parliament that, that boundary should be altered, how do you capture The electronic version of the Senate Hansard Report is for information purposes only. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Director, Hansard Services, Senate."}]}