{"count":1608389,"next":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/?format=json&page=136541","previous":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/?format=json&page=136539","results":[{"id":1381811,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381811/?format=json","text_counter":313,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"Sen. Sifuna","speaker_title":"","speaker":{"id":13599,"legal_name":"Sifuna Edwin Watenya","slug":"sifuna-edwin-watenya"},"content":"Madam Temporary Speaker, thank you for that intervention that ensures the Senators who have spoken before us can allow us to also contribute on this Bill. I will, first, start by saying that as both a lawyer and the Senator of Nairobi City County, I feel attacked this afternoon. So, allow me to start by disabusing some of the notions that have been painted. The simplest one is the accusation that came from the Senate Majority Leader that somehow he does not see why lawyers must be part of some of these bodies that are being proposed in various pieces of legislation. I wanted the Senate Majority Leader to note that if you look at the proposal in the Bill itself, it is a mediation committee we are talking about. I think I need to paint a picture for the Senate Majority Leader of what mediation entails. It is one of those Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) mechanisms that is free from the structures of litigation; a resolution of matters before our courts. There has developed an area of practice where there are people who are now experts in ADR. If you see the provision in Subsection 7 of the Bill, Sen. M. Kajwang’ The electronic version of the Senate Hansard Report is for information purposes only. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Director, Hansard Services, Senate."},{"id":1381812,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381812/?format=json","text_counter":314,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"Sen. Sifuna","speaker_title":"","speaker":{"id":13599,"legal_name":"Sifuna Edwin Watenya","slug":"sifuna-edwin-watenya"},"content":"has proposed that because this is going to be a dispute resolution mechanism, a mediation committee set up to mediate a matter of dispute between counties on a matter regarding boundaries, then the person to chair it, should be a person with 15 years’ experience in ADR. I do not think that is a misplaced suggestion. In fact, that committee would benefit immensely by having somebody, not just any lawyer or one with two or three years’ experience, in mediation. Due to the complex issues that my colleagues have raised here, the Bill has provided for someone with 15 years in ADR. I have challenged my colleagues from other professions. If we can find a doctor, including a veterinary doctor or doctor of Sen. (Dr.) Khalwale’s calibre who can do a better job at a mediation meeting than a person with 15 years’ experience in ADR, by all means, I do not think the lawyers in this House would object. What we are saying is that nobody should paint the picture that lawyers are somehow imposing themselves in places where they are not needed. This is one of the areas where a person with that experience would benefit most immensely from the job he has been asked to do. Secondly, I have heard notions here expressed about whether Nairobi needs to continue as a county. Others have suggested rightly that Nairobi needs to be managed differently and that it should no longer be a county. For me, you have to go back to the process of the review of the Constitution. I was not there. Yes, I was still in university when some of my colleagues were doing Bomas and Naivasha. However, I have had the privilege of reading the final report of the Constitution of Kenya Review Commission (CKRC). If you read that final report, you will understand the thinking that went into every specific provision of the Constitution and the architecture that we ended up with. The concept or the idea behind devolution does not change based on where the person is where they live or the circumstances in which they live. The concept of devolution is to get services and resources to the lowest possible unit of administration. The lowest unit of administration exists just as much in Nairobi as it exists in Homa Bay where the sponsor of this Bill comes from. The people of Mukuru kwa Njenga would want direct access to resources and services just the way somebody in Kanyamwaa would insist on direct access to resources and services. They also want to see the Government. If you read the CKRC report, you will remember Kenyans saying that Government is a far-off notion to them. If you talk to our brothers and sisters from the northern frontier districts, they will tell you even people moving from Mandera and Garrissa counties coming to Nairobi used to say that now we are going to Kenya. It is because of devolution that places like Turkana, Mandera and Wajir saw the first kilometre of tarmac in their counties. So, nobody can argue that a Kenyan living in Nairobi does not deserve devolution. If you recall the reasons that have been advanced by my colleagues, especially the Mover of this Motion, Sen. Kajwang’, on why he thinks Nairobi needs to be managed differently, that matter has already been thought about. The electronic version of the Senate Hansard Report is for information purposes only. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Director, Hansard Services, Senate."},{"id":1381813,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381813/?format=json","text_counter":315,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"Sen. Sifuna","speaker_title":"","speaker":{"id":13599,"legal_name":"Sifuna Edwin Watenya","slug":"sifuna-edwin-watenya"},"content":"There exists in our books a law called The Urban Areas and Cities Act. That Act is Cap 275 of the Laws of Kenya. It is still in our books. I want to refer you to the objects of this particular Bill and they are found in Section 3(b) of the Act. The Act is to provide for governance and management of urban areas and cities. If you look at Clause 4(a) of that Act which was introduced via an amendment in 2019, it provides for a mechanism for the delineation of boundaries of urban areas and cities. If you go further to Section 6 of that Act, it provides for management in that there must be a way to deal with management and infrastructure in the capital city and that they shall be managed in the same manner as county governments. Then 6(3) talks about- “The capital city shall provide the infrastructure necessary to sustain the following: The seat of the national government; offices of diplomatic missions; efficient transport network connecting to rural areas, towns and other local, regional and international cities and commerce and industry.” So, all these factors including the uniqueness of Nairobi is something that has already been anticipated and thought about. There exists a law to provide a mechanism for collaboration between the national Government and the County Government of Nairobi for us to be able to manage the unique issues that exist in Nairobi, but do not exist in Homa Bay Town. I am sure there is no diplomatic posting in Homa Bay Madam Temporary Speaker, the problem has been that if you look at Section 6 (5) of the Urban Areas and Cities Act, there is a requirement for national and county government to enter into an agreement regarding the performance of the functions and delivery of services by the capital city. This is where we are stuck. This is because the national Government has repeatedly failed to come through on its responsibilities to ensure that Nairobi City County, as a capital city, in the seat of Government and the host of diplomatic missions, undertakes these particular functions. It is compounded by the fact that national Government institutions, including Parliament, have refused to pay rates to the County Government of Nairobi. As I speak today, national Government institutions owe Nairobi City County over Kshs100 billion in unpaid rates. All these institutions that we host here, it would be easy for us to provide these services to make sure that you enjoy the sort of infrastructure you want to enjoy in the city county if the national Government did its bit. Do you know that, as I speak today, Nairobi City County has an outstanding pending bill of electricity owed to Kenya Power (KP) equivalent to the equitable share of Lamu County; a sum of Kshs2 billion? Sen. (Dr.) Khalwale comes from Kakamega County. When he tells his people he is going to Nairobi City County, there is a certain expectation of the sort of life he will live. He will not drive on dark roads as if he is driving to Musanda. He wants to drive from his home in Karen to here in the Senate, while the road he is driving on is properly lit. So, these unique needs of Nairobi City County should not make people start telling us that somehow, the people of Nairobi City County do not deserve devolution. In February 2020, I was sitting somewhere at a hotel here in Nairobi City County. A breaking news item came on the news that the then Governor Sonko was at State The electronic version of the Senate Hansard Report is for information purposes only. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Director, Hansard Services, Senate."},{"id":1381814,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381814/?format=json","text_counter":316,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"Sen. Sifuna","speaker_title":"","speaker":{"id":13599,"legal_name":"Sifuna Edwin Watenya","slug":"sifuna-edwin-watenya"},"content":"House signing a deed of transfer of functions from the County Government to the national Government. I was in shock. I could not believe it. In fact, it is the one time that I have been caught flat-footed about the possibility of such things happening under sanction our Constitution. I did not know that it could be done. I was in shock. Two months later, in April 2020, Governor Sonko was saying he signed that thing under duress. It was a dark time for those of us who believe in devolution. The question is still out there. Those of us who have the opinion that Nairobi City County needs to be managed differently, has the Nairobi Metropolitan Services (NMS) done any better? As I speak today, over Kshs20 billion is still outstanding as pending bills. They hired people the same way that the county government does. There were serious questions as to whether the NMS was following procurement procedures in some of the works that you saw being done at lightning speed. They were not as hamstrung by the same rules of procurement as the county government. We have a problem with leadership in Nairobi City County. As I have explained to you, even in 2020, part of the problem was the then leadership. Madam Temporary Speaker, I believe I have dwelt enough on this particular subject. Allow me to deal with the substance of this Bill. I beg my colleagues not to look at Nairobi City County as a problem, but as a county that needs to be managed by a manager. The people of Nairobi City County have suffrage. They deserve services being devolved to the lowest possible level. They deserve to see Members of County Assembly (MCAs); people they can ask about the road passing outside their house. They deserve to ask the Governor why the garbage at Umoja Innercore has not been collected since September. Sen. (Dr.) Khalwale, who will they ask when you tell us that there is this manager who is going to come? The experience of the NMS was that the manager for Nairobi City County was walled up at State House, an institution some of us in the opposition cannot be allowed to visit. I want to see the Governor; the person responsible for my resources, the MCA and so on and so forth. I want this House to know that those problems of overemployment and spending the bulk of the money on personal emoluments and salaries are also present in Nairobi City County. If you speak to the Finance Officer in Nairobi City County, she will tell you that the exchequer amount that comes every month is equivalent to the salary that goes out. So, very little in terms of revenue excesses is left for development, yet Nairobi City County has the potential to collect so much in terms of own source revenue. Madam Temporary Speaker, the problem is that we have not sealed loopholes. As I speak, right now in Nairobi City County Assembly, there is a serious inquiry into the revenue streams. That is whether we are collecting and whether we are managing our revenue management system. When my governor appeared before the committee that is ably led by the Senator for Homa Bay, he told us that the servers running the revenue collecting system are at City Hall and that he can see them. Sen. M. Kajwang’ will be shocked to learn today that The electronic version of the Senate Hansard Report is for information purposes only. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Director, Hansard Services, Senate."},{"id":1381815,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381815/?format=json","text_counter":317,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"Sen. Sifuna","speaker_title":"","speaker":{"id":13599,"legal_name":"Sifuna Edwin Watenya","slug":"sifuna-edwin-watenya"},"content":"nobody knows where those servers are. The MCAs have tried to ask questions, but the governor is dodgy. Nobody can show you. If we go to City Hall, which is just a walking distance from here, you will not see those servers. Madam Temporary Speaker, allow me to say that the object of the Bill sponsored by Sen. M. Kajwang’ has nothing to do with the arguments for viability of the counties. That is a discussion we had a long time ago. I remember the final Bomas Draft had proposed 14 counties. How that was decimated and we ended up with units that everybody says are not viable is a matter for history and a matter that can be corrected through proposals such as the ones that Sen. (Dr.) Khalwale is making. I am happy because Sen. M. Kajwang’ has thought about a matter that precedes the kicking in of Article 188. Article 188 of the Constitution talks about alteration of the boundaries. What Sen. M. Kajwang’ is saying is that before we get to the stage of alteration of boundaries, can we sit down and have a conversation about what the disputes are? I would be happy if this Bill was put in place as soon as yesterday, because as you know, there is a fight going on between Nyamira and Kisii counties over Keroka Town. It is because of the pressure from everyone about counties trying to raise their own-source revenues. They see Keroka Town as a place to collect own-source revenue that every county is working hard to achieve. The Bill is well thought-out. It has provided a mechanism for us to appoint a mediation committee that will be chaired by somebody with the expertise in alternative dispute resolution. It states that if you are an advocate who is guilty of professional misconduct, you cannot be eligible for appointment to these particular committees. Talking about alteration of boundaries, I have sat in the committee led by Sen. M. Kajwang’ and came to learn that people are passionate about their counties. Sen. (Dr.) Khalwale, if we were having a meeting during the Senate Mashinani, you would not have left that county if those sentiments were made on the Floor. If you go to Nyamira County and tell those people that they should be governed from Kisii, they will lynch you. If you try to convince the people of Homa Bay that if they were put together with Migori, Kisumu and Siaya they can do better, you will be lynched because there was a misconception at the beginning of devolution that counties belonged to certain people. I will not shy away from saying certain tribes. It is so bad that if you come from Bungoma, it is impossible for you to be employed in Kakamega, yet we are all Luhyas. They say; “ wewe uko na kwenu.” That is a quotation. Do not say that I have offended the Standing Orders by using another language. If you are from Bungoma, they will tell you that you also have a county and ask you to go and apply there. It is bad. In fact, the discussion within some counties is for an even greater disintegration. Sen. (Dr.) Khalwale is aware of the agitation by the people from Sabaot in Mt. Elgon in Bungoma County for them to have their own county. The Teso in Busia, or in Migori where the Kuria are, also agitating that they need their own county. For as long as that county exists to pay salaries to their children, many people are content. The electronic version of the Senate Hansard Report is for information purposes only. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Director, Hansard Services, Senate."},{"id":1381816,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381816/?format=json","text_counter":318,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"Sen. Sifuna","speaker_title":"","speaker":{"id":13599,"legal_name":"Sifuna Edwin Watenya","slug":"sifuna-edwin-watenya"},"content":"I have challenged Senators by asking; if you sat your county people down, told them you have Kshs2 billion and ask whether you should do a road or everybody to line up and get something to eat today, what do you think the people will say?"},{"id":1381817,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381817/?format=json","text_counter":319,"type":"scene","speaker_name":"","speaker_title":"","speaker":null,"content":"(An hon. Senator spoke off record)"},{"id":1381818,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381818/?format=json","text_counter":320,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"Sen. Sifuna","speaker_title":"","speaker":{"id":13599,"legal_name":"Sifuna Edwin Watenya","slug":"sifuna-edwin-watenya"},"content":"Correct, because the appreciation of devolution was misconceived at some point to mean this is ours for as long as we are eating. If it is the Bukusu eating in Bungoma, or the people of Kakamega eating in Kakamega, then there is no problem. Madam Temporary Speaker, all the disputes arise because people have sentimental values for these counties and nothing else. Proposing anything else will be very unpopular. The threshold that has been set in the Bill by the Senator for Homa Bay County, Sen. M. Kajwang’ states two-thirds of the National Assembly and two-thirds of the Senate. I believe there is also a provision that the concerned county assemblies must also participate in that decision-making. Clause 17 is on the people who can bring a Petition for alteration. The Bill lists any registered voter, a MCA, a Senator, a Member of the National Assembly and Governors. I want the proposer of the Bill to tell me why there is a difference. Probably the language in Clause 17 should be replicated in Clause 5(1), which proposes who can request for a mediation committee. Once you leave out the Members of the National Assembly under Clause 5, they might feel left out. I propose that if the Bill allows people who Petition to include Senators, MCAs and Members of the National Assembly, then it should be reflected under the qualifications of the people who can ask for a mediation committee. It also asks that the Petition for alteration must be supported by 15 per cent of the registered voters. These thresholds are reflected in other legislation. For instance, in the dissolution of county governments whenever there is a dispute between the county assembly and the governor that is irreconcilable. On the mediation committee. I had spoken to Sen. M. Kajwang’ on the language in Part III, Clause 6 because the Bill as currently drafted states- “Where a resolution has been made by the Senate for the establishment of a mediation committee under Section 5(1), the President shall, within 14 days of receipt of the resolution appoint a mediation committee with the approval of the Senate.’’ That looks like repetition because after the resolution of the Senate has been made and when the President is appointing the Committee, you do not need to approve that appointment."},{"id":1381819,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381819/?format=json","text_counter":321,"type":"scene","speaker_name":"","speaker_title":"","speaker":null,"content":"(Sen. Sifuna’s microphone was switched off)"},{"id":1381820,"url":"http://info.mzalendo.com/api/v0.1/hansard/entries/1381820/?format=json","text_counter":322,"type":"speech","speaker_name":"Sen. Mumma","speaker_title":"The Temporary Speaker","speaker":null,"content":" Sen. Sifuna, your time is up. Proceed Sen. Gataya Mo Fire. The electronic version of the Senate Hansard Report is for information purposes only. A certified version of this Report can be obtained from the Director, Hansard Services, Senate."}]}